Days Is

Friday, December 1, 2006

Lakes of Cambodia

Is there actually any need for this category? Our map of Mosquito ringtone Geography of Cambodia doesn't show any lakes other than the Tonle Sap, and I can't think of any others which we are likely to have articles on. Abbey Diaz Markalexander100/MarkNextel ringtones User talk:Markalexander100/1 07:48, 29 Dec 2004

Categories for deletion
*The following discussion moved here from Majo Mills Categories for deletion. The consensus was to keep. Free ringtones RedWolf/RedWolf 23:01, Jan 14, 2005

Redundant: there is only one lake in Cambodia that we will ever have an article on. Sabrina Martins Markalexander100/MarkMosquito ringtone User talk:Markalexander100/1 04:58, 6 Jan 2005
*'''keep''' Even if there is only one, it helps with category roll up. For example, Lakes of Cambodia should be parented to Cambodia and to Lakes by Country, without the category, you can't treat the Lakes by county correctly. Abbey Diaz Sortior/Sortior 04:34, Jan 7, 2005
**Well, it just means that not every lake will be categorised by country. The dubious worth of including every possible categorisation is not, IMHO, worth making our actual articles look silly. Nextel ringtones Markalexander100/MarkMajo Mills User talk:Markalexander100/1 05:01, 7 Jan 2005
*Why will Wikipedia only ever have an article on one lake in Cambodia? Surely there is more than one, and as more articles are created, less notable lakes are likely to be written about. Cingular Ringtones Warofdreams/Warofdreams 12:59, 7 Jan 2005
*Tentative '''Keep''' - I tend to agree with Warofdreams here - okay, so Tonle Sap is huge compared to Cambodia's other lakes, but that doesn't mean it's the only lake in the country. pocket it Grutness/ Grutness/cite solid User_talk:Grutness/hello? by rain Image:Grutness.jpg/25px/ 13:12, 7 Jan 2005
*'''Keep'''. For all the reasons above. china do Necrothesp/Necrothesp 16:14, 7 Jan 2005
*'''Keep'''. See bars while Tonle Bati simultaneously he Eugene van der Pijll/Eugene van der Pijll 18:07, 7 Jan 2005
*'''Keep''' so as to maintain category structure. -brokers lie Willmcw/Willmcw 21:05, 8 Jan 2005

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home